Carelessness? Classical "Orthodoxy"? Manufactured Coherence? Some Thoughts on Dvorak's D Minor QuartetJohannes Brahms may have accepted the dedication of Dvorakâs String Quartet in d minor, op. 34 (1877), but (in rather gentle manner for Brahms, when in a critical mood) wrote to Dvorak that when filling in the sharps and flats in his music he should take another look at the notes themselves, and noted (with implicit criticism) how quickly Dvorak composed. Is this criticism fair?
The Limitations of Nomenclature: Introductions by Beethoven and BrahmsIn the parlance of harmonic analysis, the Beethoven First Symphony and the Brahms
Ein Deutsches Requiem open with the same chord, known in the trade as V/IV, (or the dominant of the subdominant, for all you Poindexters out there) you’d think they would make a similar effect. But they don’t.
Three Sonatas and a Passacaglia; Brahms and the Symphonic FinaleBrahms allows the gypsy caravan on stage for the finales of his Piano Quartet, op. 25, Violin Concerto, op.77, and Double Concerto, op. 102. But in his symphonic finales, Romany is no longer spoken. Why?